Breathtakingly beautiful and over a billion years old, it’s no wonder diamonds symbolise everlasting love. Plus they are incredibly hardwearing and complement any outfit. Unfortunately, their potentially unethical origins far from match our values.

Thankfully ethical solutions do exist though and with guidance you can ensure your engagement ring expresses love in every way.

It’s all about considering the Transparency and Traceability of the diamond. Here are you options:

Canadian Diamonds
Diamonds from Canada’s Northwest Territories (NWT), just below the Arctic Circle, are some of the world’s most traceable and responsibly sourced. While slightly more expensive, not only are they conflict-free but government regulations enforce strict environmental and labour standards with respect for local businesses and aboriginal communities.

“Before any company can begin mining in Canada, it must calculate the impact on vegetation, air and water quality, and local wildlife sustainability, as well as the social and economic implications” – The Jewellery Editor

Cutting and polishing mainly takes place abroad since the Canadian diamond manufacturing industry is still very small but many diamonds can be traced right back to the original mine through the 5th C – certification. CanadaMark, which we use for diamonds 0.3ct and above, imposes stringent and independent checks throughout its supply chain.

Upcycled Diamonds
Regarded as the “world’s largest diamond resource” by the GIA, recycled diamonds are eco-friendly and cheaper. Although usually untraceable, they won’t contribute to further, negative mining practices or strain on finite diamond reserves.

Older diamonds may require a recut and polish but vintage cuts can stand out against contemporary styles. Whether bought from a reputable trader or part of a much-loved but outdated family heirloom, many jewellers offer a redesigning service to create a fresh, bespoke piece that fits their client’s style.

The ultimate benefit though is the story an upcycled diamond already carries, one you may be able to retell or merely fantasise about but will now add another chapter to. (A perfect example was Meghan Markle’s engagement ring)

Lab Grown Diamonds
If you want to avoid the issues associated with mining completely, man-made diamonds are becoming a viable, more sustainable alternative. Boasting a smaller carbon footprint, they are around 30% cheaper and visibly identical (without using specialist equipment) to their natural counterparts.

Cultivated in conditions simulating the geological process, they share the same chemical and optical properties and are considered real diamonds unlike imitations.

Of course, being mere weeks old, synthetics don’t have the same romantic heritage and many argue demand for them is taking work from impoverished miners operating in fair conditions. As a jeweller with a passion for traditional craftsmanship and ethical campaigner I tend to choose the first 2 options instead.

What about De Beers?
Historically, De Beers has been the main miner of diamonds in the world. Currently, the company is leading industry efforts to improve transparency and ethics but currently no De Beers diamond is fully traceable.

The company is leading industry efforts to improve transparency and ethics but only diamonds under its Forevermark brand are currently sourced responsibly.

De Beers sells 90% of its unmarked rough diamonds (which are all mixed at the sorting facility in Botswana) to authorised Sightholders. These customers range from diamond cutters to global manufacturers and they’ll usually source diamonds from other mining companies too.

While De Beers enforces a strict code of conduct for itself and its Sightholders, it’s impossible to guarantee a Sightholder won’t mix diamonds. Therefore, an ethical jeweller should only work with suppliers they trust and who respect provenance.

engagement ring
Meghan Markle Replica Ring by Jewlr.com. The Duchess Ring with Accent Stones is inspired by the Royal Engagement. (CNW Group/Jewlr)

And the Kimberley Process?
Unfortunately this international certification scheme, launched in 2003 to stem the flow of blood diamonds, is not only flawed but can be misleading.

The trading system amongst its 81 member countries is susceptible to smuggling and the term ‘conflict diamond’ merely covers gems used to fund rebel groups. As such, KP-certified diamonds may still be associated with violence and human rights abuses by government armies, worker exploitation and environmental degradation.

From 2018, the process is undergoing a two-year systemic review but, until reform is implemented, jewellers cannot rely on the Kimberley Process alone to guarantee a diamond is conflict-free and ethical.

Top tip: go for a traceable gemstone
Did you know diamond engagement rings have only become a tradition in the last 70 years thanks to De Beers’ powerful marketing slogan ‘A Diamond is Forever’?

In fact coloured gemstones are becoming increasingly fashionable again with millennials seeking bolder, unique and more personal styles. This revival happens to coincide with a rise in ethical and traceable options too.

If you’re seeking something a little more individual, our magnificent sapphires and rubies are mined under fair trade principles and can be traced right back to the source. See our gemstones engagement rings here.

You can read all about Arabel Lebrusan’s ethics on their website.